Rating: BIG portions & great food! 10/12/2017
Reviewer: Avon Lady

We ate here for the first time this past September & the breakfast was delicious!! I had the sausage & egg biscuit (biscuits – 2 large breakfast sandwiches)… it was fantastic, had to take the 2nd home, and the potatoes were great!!! Hubby had pancake, eggs & bacon & he was more than happy. Place was very clean, fast & friendly staff. We will be back soon!!!

Rating: Tradition 5/4/2006
Reviewer: Pat Perks

We usually do breakfast at the house but make a point of eating our one breakfast out here. I love the food and the atmosphere. Everyone likes the pony potatoes. This is the 1st place we ate on our 1st trip to the OBX in 1989

Rating: This is a place that never changes, and it shouldn't... 8/1/2005
Reviewer: Anonymous

If you're looking for traditional, southern cooking, the Pony Island is the place for you. My family has been visiting the island for 40+ years, and hardly anything has changed at the Pony. You can always count on great food, and the same friendly wait staff. For breakfast, don't miss the "pony potatoes". For dinner, the fried chicken is truly out of this world.

Rating: True ocracoke morning - southern style 3/31/2005
Reviewer: penny

This is a nice family restaurant where you can have mexican omelettes or traditional western omelette. Southern hospitality and famous grits.