OBX Connection Home > OBX Connection Forum > Best OBX seafood dish in years
Best OBX seafood dish in years

Best OBX seafood dish in years




We have lived in OBX for 8 years and eat out a few times per month. Largely we have been disappointed in the quality of fish dishes…high priced and not that great at a variety of restaurants (including ones where you would expect great food). Tonight we had a red snapper special at Goombays and it was HANDS DOWN the best fish dish we have eaten since we moved here. So good! We will be eating more there in the future.


OBX Connection Sponsored Links




RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




I had dinner at Goombay's last week. I had a shrimp pasta dish and it was pretty good. I'll try the fish next time, thanks for the tip!

It wasn't my first visit there, but it had been many years. I thought it was strange they didn't have prices on the menu but provided a separate "price list". I guess due to price fluctuations? Still, it was odd.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Red snapper is a super tasting fish. I used to eat it when I lived in the Tampa Bay area in the late 70s but seldom have the opportunity now.

Click to follow link...




RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Two nights ago I had the blackened snapper at Diamond Shoals and I raved to my family it was the most flavorful and juicy fish I had ever had. We have eaten there several times on each trip to Hatteras over decades but the entire meal this time was beyond just good into the realm of exceptional.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Snapper is up there at the top of the universal "Taste" Polls. Found worldwide there are many types of Snapper, the Red being the most popular Restaurant Fish in the US. A lot of credit must go to the Chefs and Recipes. This can "Make or Break" the taste. As a local I encourage you to try some local species if you can find them. These will most likely be "Specials" on menus, Tilefish (Our local Blueline), Black Sea Bass and Sheepshead. There are so many tastes in food. The flesh quality in fish is far ranging, you have firm, big flakes or softer flesh that runs together. The tastes run from tasteless to fishy (yes some fish are more fishy). Just an observation on that link above. It has Bluefish near the top. Ugh, see what I mean. Mangia!


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Mangrove (aka gray) snapper is also delicious. It is local to Florida but if you see it on the menu, don't pass it up. Sweet, flaky and crispy if grilled.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




I need to put Goombays on my short list. I’ve never been. I’ve had good seafood at Blue Moon and Bluewater. Food Dudes does a tuna bowl (not poke) that’s to die for, but it’s just a bit too much food. I ask for just a quick sear so it’s still raw and they nail it.

Yellowfin with a short marinade in soy/mirin/honey/sesame oil pan seared just to cook the outer 1/8” with a cool/raw interior gets my vote as best tasting! Tilefish is superb and fried puppy drum is delish. Skin on speckled trout pan seared so the skin becomes like a crispy chip is excellent as well.

This is the marinade and sauce recipe I use for tuna. It pairs great with a tuna loin from Fresh Catch! Click to follow link...


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Had blackand tuna at Mahi Mahi 3 days ago that was fantastic. Go try anything at The Salt Box on Colington road - you will thank me when you do. Their fish specials are always GREAT, and it will be fresh.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Snapper is up there at the top of the universal "Taste" Polls. Found worldwide there are many types of Snapper, the Red being the most popular Restaurant Fish in the US. A lot of credit must go to the Chefs and Recipes. This can "Make or Break" the taste. As a local I encourage you to try some local species if you can find them. These will most likely be "Specials" on menus, Tilefish (Our local Blueline), Black Sea Bass and Sheepshead. There are so many tastes in food. The flesh quality in fish is far ranging, you have firm, big flakes or softer flesh that runs together. The tastes run from tasteless to fishy (yes some fish are more fishy). Just an observation on that link above. It has Bluefish near the top. Ugh, see what I mean. Mangia!

Pickle


Bluefish would certainly not be in my top 10 list either. And I’ve had plenty of chances to eat it. I have not had the opportunity to try bluefin tuna, but my top 10 list is:


Rockfish
Mahi-mahi
Red snapper
Salmon
Halibut
Grouper
Swordfish
Yellow fin tuna
Speckled trout
Flounder


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Just an observation on that link above. It has Bluefish near the top. Ugh, see what I mean. Mangia!

Pickle


Fresh out of the drink Bluefish can be very good. Not sure it's a top 10 in the WORLD, but what the hay, Anchovies and catfish made that particular list, so take it for what it's worth.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Snapper is up there at the top of the universal "Taste" Polls. Found worldwide there are many types of Snapper, the Red being the most popular Restaurant Fish in the US. A lot of credit must go to the Chefs and Recipes. This can "Make or Break" the taste. As a local I encourage you to try some local species if you can find them. These will most likely be "Specials" on menus, Tilefish (Our local Blueline), Black Sea Bass and Sheepshead. There are so many tastes in food. The flesh quality in fish is far ranging, you have firm, big flakes or softer flesh that runs together. The tastes run from tasteless to fishy (yes some fish are more fishy). Just an observation on that link above. It has Bluefish near the top. Ugh, see what I mean. Mangia!

Pickle


Bluefish would certainly not be in my top 10 list either. And I’ve had plenty of chances to eat it. I have not had the opportunity to try bluefin tuna, but my top 10 list is:


Rockfish
Mahi-mahi
Red snapper
Salmon
Halibut
Grouper
Swordfish
Yellow fin tuna
Speckled trout
Flounder

ezbuckwheat


I would be interested in hearing everyone’s top 10 list, especially yours Pickle considering your background. There are lots of species of fish that I have not tried, but would like to.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




“Fresh out of the drink Bluefish can be very good”

Down in the Florida Keys, they say the same thing about barracuda. Anybody tried it?


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




“Fresh out of the drink Bluefish can be very good”

Down in the Florida Keys, they say the same thing about barracuda. Anybody tried it?

ezbuckwheat



Too risky because if cig poisoning. Unless you want to be hugging the bowl for a few days, don’t try the cuda.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Just an observation on that link above. It has Bluefish near the top. Ugh, see what I mean. Mangia!

Pickle


Fresh out of the drink Bluefish can be very good. Not sure it's a top 10 in the WORLD, but what the hay, Anchovies and catfish made that particular list, so take it for what it's worth.

Stumpy


I used to catch a good many blue fish in the Chesapeake but never cared for eating them until one day we cooked one up that came right off the boat and it was far better than after a few hours or days later.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Quite true, Tim. Fresh blue is good, but it needs to be bled immediately and eaten the same day.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Okay somebody asked for my favorites. As I said Everyone's taste is different and then you have various cooking methods. Having grown up in NY in a Fishing Family, both Recreational and Commercial and having been here for 30 running a Charterboat and a very close relationship to our Commercial Fishing Heritage I will mix my favorites in no real order:
Tilefish (both Blueline and Golden)
Cod and it's cousin the Haddock
Black Sea Bass
Sheepshead
Triggerfish
Fluke (Without getting into an argument, our NC Flounder)
Tautog (Blackfish)
Trout (both Gray and Speckled)
Blowfish (aka Blowtoads, Puffers etc.)
Grouper

If you are Familiar with fish you'll readily see I like "Bottom" fish or you might say I don't like Fishy Tasting Fish. I like Flaky Flesh, not tight or soft continuous "Fleshed". So lets leave you all the Tuna, Wahoo, King Mackerel and Dolphin you want. Locally I can give a vote for Spanish Mackerel. Enjoy your Fish, whatever specie it may be.


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Croaker
Pompano
Grouper
Red Snapper
Cobia
Lionfish
Dolphin (Mahi-mahi, Dorado)
Swordfish
Drum
Flounder



RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Dolphin (Mahi-mahi, Dorado)

lowtide


Going way back, Tortugas Lie was called "Quagmires". (The first one.)

One of the partners was John Kirchmier and on his menu, next to the "Dolphin" item was this: "No, it's not Flipper!"

Many customers did not know there was a dolphin fish and asked if it was Porpoise! The Hawaiian name for Dolphin is Mahi Mahi and that became the preferred name as restaurants got tired of explaining the difference!


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




I really admire any restaurant that uses the correct name, Dolphin. Did you know that Jellyfish is not correct, it is now just Jellies? A very Famous Chinese guy said "Can't Teach an Old Dog New Tricks". Have a GRRRRRREAT day!


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




I cannot order Mahi-mahi at a restaurant without extending my pinky finger..... Fish Fish


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




As Buckwheat said, there are so many I have not had.

As Pickle said, there are so many different cooking methods. Grouper prepared one way might be #1. Prepared another way, not so much.

In no particular order...

Grouper
Snapper
Tile
Trigger
Pompano
Whiting
Spanish
Spot
Mahi
Tuna (YF, never had any of the others fresh).




RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




Okay somebody asked for my favorites. As I said Everyone's taste is different and then you have various cooking methods. Having grown up in NY in a Fishing Family, both Recreational and Commercial and having been here for 30 running a Charterboat and a very close relationship to our Commercial Fishing Heritage I will mix my favorites in no real order:
Tilefish (both Blueline and Golden)
Cod and it's cousin the Haddock
Black Sea Bass
Sheepshead
Triggerfish
Fluke (Without getting into an argument, our NC Flounder)
Tautog (Blackfish)
Trout (both Gray and Speckled)
Blowfish (aka Blowtoads, Puffers etc.)
Grouper

If you are Familiar with fish you'll readily see I like "Bottom" fish or you might say I don't like Fishy Tasting Fish. I like Flaky Flesh, not tight or soft continuous "Fleshed". So lets leave you all the Tuna, Wahoo, King Mackerel and Dolphin you want. Locally I can give a vote for Spanish Mackerel. Enjoy your Fish, whatever specie it may be.

Pickle




Thanks, Pickle. There are two on your list I have not tried, the blowfish (I thought they were poisonous) and the tautog. I am going to give the tautog a try. Would I be able to find it locally?
There is a Tautog’s Restaurant in Virginia Beach, but I could not find the fish on their menu.

I am surprised that no one has rockfish on their top 10 list. I know a lot of people around here who would have it near the top. Perhaps it’s because we grew up with it being so plentiful.

The tautog showed up as number one on another list I found.


Click to follow link...


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




I loved orange roughy but can't find it anymore


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




$3,100,000.00 for one fish! No wonder I have never tried bluefin tuna

Click to follow link...


RE: Best OBX seafood dish in years




I had dinner at Goombay's last week. I had a shrimp pasta dish and it was pretty good. I'll try the fish next time, thanks for the tip!

It wasn't my first visit there, but it had been many years. I thought it was strange they didn't have prices on the menu but provided a separate "price list". I guess due to price fluctuations? Still, it was odd.

Anchee


We just got back from a visit to Busch Gardens. On every receipt was a "5% Surcharge." That was for increaseed operating costs. The expense of eating out is definitely going up, and it's harder on restaurants than ever. The profit margin for most restaurants hovers at around 5%. Dosn't sound like much of a profit, does it?

Click to follow link...


OBX Connection Sponsored Links